KBS Reference Desk: Political Dress

Q:        We recently received a complaint about a teacher wearing a Trump/Pence t-shirt during virtual instruction. Our dress code prohibits all clothing with a political message—the teacher claims we are violating her right to free speech. Can our district regulate the employee’s political clothing?

A:        Likely yes, but there are two issues to consider. 1) First Amendment implications and 2) state prohibition against political advertising and electioneering utilizing public funds.

First Amendment.  As noted by the Supreme Court, while school district employees do not lose their First Amendment Rights “at the schoolhouse gate,” this protection is not limitless, and employers may exercise a considerable degree of control over employees’ work-related communications and expression. As such, in this case, the district’s dress code regulation banning all clothing/garments bearing a political message is enforceable, as it is viewpoint-neutral and relates directly to employee’s work-related expression.  As in the hypothetical above, it is recommended that a district’s employee handbook contain a provision prohibiting clothing with non-school messages. Without such language, the district will be required to apply a First Amendment analysis to each scenario in order to determine whether the teacher’s “speech” is protected. If faced with this analysis, the key factors include whether the employee’s speech involves a matter of public concern, the school’s interest in regulating the speech, and the application of the district’s regulations, if any, in a reasonable, viewpoint-neutral manner.

Political Advertising/Electioneering. Use of employee equipment, such as a computer, by a teacher during instructional time to convey a political message likely violates state law prohibitions against political advertising and electioneering through the use of public funds. Both the Texas Education Code and the Texas Election Code forbid electioneering and political advertising through the use of state funds. See Tex. Educ. Code § 11.169; Tex. Elec. Code § 255.003. The Texas Ethics Commission broadly interprets “public funds” to include use of school employee time and use of school equipment such as computers. Thus, use of a district computer to convey a political message through the teacher’s clothing during instructional time may constitute an impermissible use of public funds for electioneering and/or political advertising.

The state law prohibiting political advertising factors into the First Amendment analysis as well. For instance, if a school district did not have a dress code that prohibited the clothing, when analyzing the school’s interest in regulating the political speech—compliance with state law weighs heavily in favor of the district’s interest in ensuring compliance with the Education and Election Codes. This would be true whether a computer and distance learning was in play or not.

In light of the Supreme Court’s analysis of the First Amendment and state election laws, employees who wish to engage in political advocacy should do so on their own time and without using district equipment, time or resources. Wearing a political t-shirt or button supporting or opposing a specific candidate or measure while on duty, including while providing virtual instruction, is most likely in violation of state law concerning political speech at work, and not protected speech for purposes of the First Amendment.

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Recent Articles

KBS Reference Desk: Evaluating SPED Teachers after COVID-19
April 2, 2021
KBS Reference Desk: Pay During Closure
February 26, 2021
KBS Reference Desk: Virtual Learning and Child Find
February 5, 2021
KBS Reference Desk: American Rescue Plan
January 29, 2021
KBS Reference Desk: TOMA Suspension Extension – Additional 30 days
January 15, 2021
KBS Reference Desk: Updated FFCRA Guidance
January 8, 2021
KBS Reference Desk: New Stay-at-Home Protocols
December 18, 2020
KBS Reference Desk: Vaccine as a Requirement for School Attendance
December 11, 2020
KBS Reference Desk: Campus Closure due to COVID-19 and Funding
December 4, 2020
KBS Reference Desk: Nonexempt Volunteer Work
November 20, 2020
KBS Reference Desk: TPIA – 10-day Extension
November 6, 2020
KBS Reference Desk: Discontinue Virtual Learning
October 30, 2020
KBS Reference Desk: Emergency Safety Drills
October 16, 2020
KBS Reference Desk: Requests for Homebound Instruction During COVID
October 9, 2020
KBS Reference Desk: Mask Exception
October 2, 2020
KBS Reference Desk: UIL Football Streaming
September 26, 2020
KBS Reference Desk: Eligible Expenses Under Coronavirus Relief Fund
September 18, 2020
KBS Reference Desk: Confidentiality and the ADA
September 11, 2020
KBS Reference Desk: Threat Assessment
September 4, 2020
KBS Reference Desk: Emergency Board Meetings
August 28, 2020
KBS Reference Desk: Homebound Services
August 21, 2020
KBS Reference Desk: COVID-19 Student Privacy and Virtual Learning
August 14, 2020
KBS Reference Desk: ADA Accommodations Based on Family Member’s Disability
August 7, 2020
KBS Reference Desk: EPSL EFML
July 31, 2020
KBS Reference Desk: Payment Guarantee Requests Due to COVID-19
July 24, 2020